The SUV segment is a diverse landscape, raising the fundamental question: What truly defines an SUV? Is it simply a truck with an enclosed cargo area, or a more refined, taller vehicle offering enhanced capabilities compared to a standard sedan? Modern SUVs present varied interpretations. The 2023 Toyota 4Runner, for instance, embodies the traditional truck-based SUV ethos with robust off-road prowess. Conversely, the 2023 Nissan Pathfinder adopts a more contemporary crossover approach, delivering SUV aesthetics with car-like driving dynamics. To discern which model better aligns with your needs, we conducted a comprehensive comparison, pitting the 4Runner against the Pathfinder, and further evaluating the off-road-oriented Pathfinder Rock Creek Edition. This in-depth review analyzes these two mid-size SUVs across eight critical categories, culminating in an overall recommendation to guide your purchasing decision.
Pricing and Value Proposition
The 2023 Nissan Pathfinder presents a compelling entry point, starting at $35,000. This base price includes a generous array of standard features encompassing safety, comfort, and convenience. Progressing to the SV trim, priced at $37,820, further enhances the value with additional amenities. The leather-appointed SL variant is available for $41,420, while the top-tier Platinum model, exemplified by our test vehicle, commences at $47,940. The newly introduced Rock Creek Edition, comparable in equipment to an all-wheel-drive SV, starts at $42,820, representing a $3,100 premium over the SV trim. Nissan’s pricing strategy positions the Pathfinder as an accessible and feature-rich option in its class.
Conversely, the Toyota 4Runner, while also offering a solid list of standard features – some of which are reserved for higher Pathfinder trims, such as a power driver’s seat and adaptive cruise control – commands a higher base price. The base 4Runner SR5 starts at $39,555, exceeding the price of a better-equipped Pathfinder SV. Leatherette upholstery necessitates upgrading to at least the $42,615 trim, and genuine leather is only available on the $48,790 Limited model or higher. While Toyota provides enhanced off-road focused features and the 4Runner is recognized for its strong resale value, the Nissan Pathfinder maintains a clear advantage in terms of initial purchase price, offering considerable value for money.
Exterior Styling and Design
The Toyota 4Runner, with its last redesign dating back to 2010, embodies a distinctly rugged and truck-like aesthetic, even by the standards of its time. In today’s market, its robust design language stands out even more prominently. The vertical front fascia, particularly on the TRD Pro trim, exudes a battering-ram-like presence. The front bumper’s upward curvature enhances off-road clearance, complemented by visible protective skid plates underneath. Squared-off, flared fenders and a boxy body contribute to its chunky, muscular appeal. Grille designs vary across 4Runner trims; luxury-oriented models feature a segmented grille, while off-road versions incorporate a larger, more protected lower section. The TRD Pro variant replaces the traditional oval Toyota emblem with assertive lettering, further emphasizing its off-road intent.
In contrast, the latest Nissan Pathfinder, introduced for the 2022 model year, showcases a more refined and contemporary design language compared to its softer predecessor. It presents a trim and crisp appearance, characterized by taut lines and a tailored silhouette. While maintaining similar boxy proportions to the 4Runner, the Pathfinder incorporates sophisticated details, including a prominent chrome grille and headlight spears that elegantly extend towards the hood. Beyond mere elegance, the Pathfinder is styled to project a tougher image than many of its crossover competitors, especially in the Rock Creek Edition guise. This trim enhances its rugged appeal with a raised suspension, off-road wheels and tires, additional body cladding, and a tubular roof rack. However, it remains fundamentally less truck-like than the Toyota 4Runner. Ultimately, exterior design preference is subjective and depends on individual aesthetic tastes.
Tie
Interior Design and Technology
Mirroring its exterior, the Toyota 4Runner’s interior prioritizes durability and functionality over opulent aesthetics. Oversized climate control knobs are both user-friendly and reminiscent of a bygone era when SUVs were utilitarian workhorses. However, Toyota has integrated modern technology, including an 8-inch infotainment touchscreen introduced in the 2020 model year.
Despite these updates, certain aspects of the 4Runner’s interior feel dated. While contemporary outdoorsy SUVs have embraced rugged yet premium materials, the 4Runner’s interior largely consists of basic plastics. In comparison, the Nissan Pathfinder presents a more upscale cabin environment, characterized by richer materials and refined tactile elements. It also surpasses the 4Runner in infotainment technology, offering a larger 9-inch touchscreen on higher trims. Even the Rock Creek Edition’s 8-inch unit boasts superior graphics and responsiveness compared to the Toyota system. The Pathfinder’s angular dashboard design aligns with SUV styling cues, yet most trims lean towards luxury-oriented appointments rather than overtly rugged themes. While the Pathfinder excels in technology and material quality, interior design preference remains a matter of personal taste.
Interior Space and Passenger Comfort
For buyers prioritizing passenger capacity or cargo volume, careful consideration of interior space is crucial. Both the Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota 4Runner offer optional third-row seating, but their configurations and capacities differ significantly. The Pathfinder’s third row, standard across all trims, accommodates up to three passengers. In contrast, the 4Runner’s third row is an optional feature on select models and seats only two. Both third rows are compact, but the 4Runner’s is notably more restrictive. However, for those primarily needing seating for five, the 4Runner excels in cargo capacity, offering a generous 47.2 cubic feet behind the second row and 89.7 cubic feet with the second row folded. The Pathfinder provides 45.0 cubic feet behind the second row and 80.5 cubic feet with the second row folded. Notably, the Pathfinder offers superior cargo space with the third row in use (16.6 cubic feet vs. 9 cubic feet). Both SUVs provide comfortable front and second-row seating, making this category a subjective tie depending on specific space priorities.
Tie
Driving Performance and Handling
The Toyota 4Runner delivers a driving experience characteristic of a traditional truck-based SUV. Its 270-horsepower 4.0-liter V6 engine produces a robust roar upon ignition and under acceleration. It confidently absorbs bumps and road imperfections, reinforcing its rugged persona. This characterful driving experience may appeal to buyers seeking a departure from the refined smoothness of typical crossovers. However, in terms of overall driving dynamics, the Nissan Pathfinder emerges as the more refined choice.
The Pathfinder prioritizes composed and competent on-road performance. Its nine-speed automatic transmission offers snappier shifts compared to the 4Runner’s dated five-speed unit. On-road handling is nimble and controlled, contributing to a driving experience that evokes a well-built, premium vehicle. The Pathfinder feels quick, quiet, agile, and comfortable, exhibiting characteristics more akin to a luxury car. With slightly more horsepower (284 hp), a more sophisticated transmission, and a lighter chassis, the Pathfinder delivers significantly quicker acceleration than the 4Runner. While some drivers may prefer the 4Runner’s raw, truck-like driving feel, the Pathfinder’s superior overall competence and refinement are undeniable. The Rock Creek Edition slightly compromises on-road crispness, but the Pathfinder still maintains a clear advantage in driving dynamics.
Off-Road Capability and Towing
When venturing off paved roads, the Toyota 4Runner demonstrates exceptional capability, rivaling almost any stock four-wheel-drive vehicle. Available off-road features include a two-speed transfer case, a locking rear differential, selectable terrain modes, Crawl Control (for automated low-speed obstacle negotiation), and a system to disconnect sway bars for enhanced wheel articulation. The tested TRD Pro model further enhances off-road prowess with Fox high-performance shocks, retuned springs, a robust front skid plate, and all-terrain tires.
The Nissan Pathfinder, while designed as a car-based crossover, offers respectable capability for its class. It boasts a higher towing capacity of 6,000 pounds, surpassing the 4Runner’s 5,000-pound limit. Dedicated off-road modes for sand and mud/ruts enhance traction in challenging conditions. The Pathfinder is well-equipped to handle typical inclement weather and unpaved surfaces. However, the 4Runner’s robust truck-based platform and specialized off-road hardware enable it to confidently tackle significantly more challenging terrain and recreational off-roading pursuits. The Pathfinder, transitioning from a traditional SUV before 2013, is now primarily engineered for on-road use, with a sedan-like 7.1 inches of ground clearance (or 7.7 inches for the Rock Creek Edition) compared to the 4Runner’s substantial 9.6 inches.
Fuel Efficiency and Economy
The Toyota 4Runner, characterized by its heavy-duty suspension, boxy design, and older powertrain, exhibits subpar fuel economy figures. EPA estimates are 16 mpg city, 19 mpg highway, and 17 mpg combined for both rear-wheel and four-wheel drive configurations. Real-world testing of our 4WD model yielded an average of just 16 mpg in mixed highway and rural driving conditions.
The Nissan Pathfinder demonstrates significantly superior fuel efficiency. Most trims achieve EPA estimates of 21 mpg city, 27 mpg highway, and 23 mpg combined for front-wheel drive, and 21 mpg city, 26 mpg highway, and 23 mpg combined for AWD. The AWD Platinum trim slightly reduces figures to 20 mpg city, 25 mpg highway, and 22 mpg combined, while the Rock Creek Edition, due to its increased ride height and roof rack, achieves 20 mpg city, 23 mpg highway, and 21 mpg combined. Real-world testing yielded 23 mpg in the Platinum and 21 mpg in the Rock Creek Edition – representing substantial improvements of 44 percent and 31 percent, respectively, over the 4Runner’s observed fuel economy.
Safety Ratings and Features
As a modern, family-oriented crossover, the Nissan Pathfinder excels in safety evaluations and incorporates a comprehensive suite of advanced safety technologies. Conversely, the Toyota 4Runner, given its older platform, lags behind in certain safety aspects.
The 4Runner’s aging design means it predates some contemporary crash test standards. It received a Marginal rating (the second-lowest) in the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s small-overlap frontal impact test. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration awarded it three out of five stars for front-passenger protection in frontal impacts and four out of five stars overall. While Toyota has incrementally added safety features to the 4Runner, including standard blind-spot monitoring, it still lacks the Pathfinder’s available lane-keeping steering assist and rear automatic emergency braking. The Pathfinder offers a more comprehensive and up-to-date safety package.
Final Verdict: The Sensible Choice
For buyers prioritizing traditional SUV ruggedness and off-road capability, the 2023 Nissan Pathfinder may not be the ideal choice. While the Rock Creek Edition adds some off-road styling and features, it doesn’t transform the Pathfinder into a hardcore off-roader capable of tackling extreme trails like the Toyota 4Runner TRD Pro.
However, for those seeking a blend of character and practicality in a mid-size SUV, the decision becomes more nuanced. The 2023 Toyota 4Runner possesses a certain authentic rugged charm and offers respectable cargo space and a decent array of modern features. Yet, it suffers from significant drawbacks, including poor fuel economy, weaker crash test scores, and a higher price point for comparable features. The latest Nissan Pathfinder, in contrast, avoids blandness with its sharper styling, more refined interior, and improved driving dynamics. While not flawless, the Pathfinder emerges as the more sensible and well-rounded choice for most buyers in the mid-size SUV segment, offering a compelling combination of practicality, refinement, and modern features without sacrificing all sense of SUV character.
Nissan Pathfinder
