Navigating the new car market can be daunting, especially with the average new car price in the U.S. hovering around $48,641 as of January. However, Consumer Reports’ latest top picks list for 2025 models offers a beacon of hope for budget-conscious buyers. The renowned publication emphasizes that you don’t need to break the bank to acquire a vehicle that excels in safety, reliability, and overall owner satisfaction. In fact, some of their top selections start at a surprisingly affordable $21,590 MSRP.
“You don’t have to spend that much to get a car that’s going to be safe and reliable and enjoyable to own,” emphasizes Alex Knizek, associate director of auto test development for Consumer Reports. This year’s list also highlights the increasing prominence of hybrid vehicles, featuring hybrids in six out of ten categories, including three plug-in hybrid options. Consumer Reports’ rigorous testing process involves purchasing vehicles anonymously and subjecting them to over 50 tests after a 2,000-mile break-in period. Their analysis also incorporates reliability and owner satisfaction surveys to ensure comprehensive evaluations.
Small Car: Nissan Sentra
The Nissan Sentra stands out in the small car category for its unexpectedly spacious cabin and agile handling. Consumer Reports highlights its fuel efficiency and a robust suite of standard active safety features that often surpass those found in more expensive competitors. For drivers seeking a practical and economical sedan, the Sentra presents a compelling option in the 2025 model year.
Subcompact SUV: Subaru Crosstrek
The Subaru Crosstrek earns its place as a top subcompact SUV due to its blend of fuel economy, generous ground clearance, and standard all-wheel drive. This combination makes it equally adept at navigating city streets and venturing onto more adventurous terrains. Consumer Reports praises the Crosstrek’s user-friendly controls and comfortable seating in both the front and rear. While the base trim engine is noted as less powerful, the upgraded 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine available in higher trims provides a more spirited driving experience.
Compact SUV: Subaru Forester
The 2025 Subaru Forester is recognized by Consumer Reports as a highly practical compact SUV, especially with its recent redesign. The updated model boasts a quieter cabin and increased cargo space compared to its predecessor. Key factors contributing to the Forester’s consistent top pick status for 12 years running include its excellent visibility, fuel efficiency, and standard all-wheel-drive system, making it a reliable and versatile choice for SUV buyers.
Midsized Car: Toyota Camry
Completely redesigned for 2025, the Toyota Camry continues its legacy as a top midsized car. Consumer Reports describes the new Camry, now exclusively offered as a hybrid, as comfortable, practical, and user-friendly. The sedan delivers a smooth ride coupled with responsive handling, solidifying its position as a dependable and efficient option in the competitive midsize sedan segment.
Small Pickup: Ford Maverick/Maverick Hybrid
The Ford Maverick and Maverick Hybrid secure their spot as a top small pickup due to their appealing price point, well-designed interior, and easy maneuverability. While the standard 250-hp turbocharged four-cylinder engine offers ample power, Consumer Reports highlights the 191-hp hybrid version as the “real draw” for its exceptional fuel economy, achieving 37 mpg in their testing. Knizek notes the Maverick’s unique appeal, bridging the gap between car-like driving dynamics and truck-like utility.
Fuel-Efficient SUV: Toyota RAV4 PHEV
For buyers prioritizing fuel efficiency in an SUV, the Toyota RAV4 PHEV (Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle) is Consumer Reports’ top recommendation. This compact plug-in hybrid SUV surpasses other RAV4 models in performance, accelerating from 0 to 60 mph in just over six seconds in their tests and offering an impressive electric range of up to 42 miles. As a plug-in hybrid, it provides a practical stepping stone for those considering full electric vehicle ownership.
Midsized SUV: Toyota Highlander Hybrid
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid earns recognition as a top midsized SUV for its excellent fuel economy, three-row seating capacity, and standard all-wheel drive. Consumer Reports’ testing yielded 35 mpg for this hybrid SUV, further emphasizing its efficiency. Described as a “smart, versatile vehicle,” the Highlander Hybrid offers comfortable rear seats, a smooth ride, responsive handling, and a comprehensive suite of safety features, making it an ideal family vehicle.
Electric Vehicle: Tesla Model Y
In the electric vehicle category, the Tesla Model Y stands out as Consumer Reports’ top pick. Its hatchback body style distinguishes it from other Tesla models, offering enhanced practicality. Praised for its blend of practicality and engaging performance, the Model Y delivers impressive acceleration and a modern design aesthetic. Improved reliability has contributed to the Model Y’s return to the top picks list, with Consumer Reports noting Tesla’s refined manufacturing process for this particular model, leading to consistent dependability.
Luxury Compact SUV: Lexus NX350h/450h+
The Lexus NX350h and NX450h+ models top the luxury compact SUV category, offering a combination of luxurious comfort and efficient performance. Consumer Reports highlights the plush seating, user-friendly infotainment system, and a refined yet controlled ride. Both the traditional hybrid NX350h, achieving 38 mpg in testing, and the plug-in hybrid NX450h+, with a 37-mile electric range and 35 mpg on gasoline, demonstrate Lexus’ commitment to both luxury and efficiency.
Luxury Midsized SUV: BMW X5/X5 PHEV
Concluding the list is the BMW X5 and X5 PHEV, Consumer Reports’ top luxury midsized SUV picks. The base X5 delivers rapid acceleration and 23 mpg, while the plug-in hybrid variant boasts an electric range of up to 39 miles and 21 mpg when running on gasoline. Both models are praised for their exceptionally quiet cabins, richly appointed interiors, and supportive seats, providing a premium driving experience.
Consumer Reports’ 2025 top picks emphasize that finding the best car in 2025 doesn’t necessitate extravagant spending. Reliability, safety, and fuel efficiency are achievable across various vehicle categories, with hybrid technology playing an increasingly significant role in delivering both performance and economy. This list serves as a valuable guide for consumers seeking informed and practical choices in the new car market.
